Mentoring essential for gender equality say top business women
9 Nov 2010
Top Australian business women believe that mentoring young women would prove more valuable than quotas in improving gender equality at senior levels of business.
Almost three quarters of respondents (72 per cent) to a survey of state winners and finalists of the 2010 Telstra Business Women’s Awards nominated mentoring programs for talented young women as vital for greater gender equality.
Eighty-three per cent of the women surveyed said mentoring should be an essential component of a positive business culture while almost two-thirds of the women (65 per cent) said they have enjoyed the benefits of a mentor during their business careers.
Only 15 per cent favoured gender quotas in the hiring, retaining or development of women as an initiative to aid gender equality. The second-highest ranked measure was flexible working conditions and locations (60 per cent) while 40 per cent of respondents nominated practices that encourage women to apply for new roles.
The survey conducted during the past fortnight and consisting of 68 successful business women from across Australia, was released as 38 women across Australia prepare to attend the Telstra Australian Business Women’s Awards in Melbourne following their earlier success in the state and territory Awards.
The responses were split almost equally on the question of whether business should comply with government-enforceable quotas, if established, on the number of senior and middle management positions occupied by women, subject to competency standards.
Thirty-nine per cent supported the proposition but 42 per cent said business should not have to comply with quotas. While 34 per cent of those surveyed believed it should be mandatory for businesses to set publicly-reported, measurable targets for the number of women at senior and middle management, 54 per cent did not agree.
When asked to nominate the biggest obstacles to women progressing to senior roles:
- 68 per cent chose the difficulties of juggling work and life responsibilities;
- 57 per cent said women’s confidence held them back; and
- 35 per cent nominated a lack of awareness about the value that gender equality can deliver to business performance.
Lack of affordable, reliable childcare was nominated by 71 per cent of those surveyed as one of the biggest obstacles to women returning to work after having children. Sixty-three per cent chose a lack of flexible working arrangements while 38 per cent said the paucity of female role models managing senior business roles was another of the key barriers.
Forty-five per cent of those surveyed said they had experienced barriers in their career advancement that they attributed to gender bias.
Telstra Chief Marketing Officer and Telstra Business Women’s Awards Ambassador Kate McKenzie said the 2010 Awards finalists and winners surveyed were successful business women whose views provided a valuable insight into issues currently facing women in the workplace.
“These outstanding women are business owners or managers in a diverse range of industries, government and not-for-profit organisations whose achievements inspire others.”
The national finals of the Telstra Business Women’s Awards, now in their 16th year, will be held in Melbourne on 11 November, where the 2010 Telstra Australian Business Woman of the Year will be announced.
State and territory winners and national winners of the TBWAs will share more than $200,000 in overall cash and prizes and join an alumni of outstanding past winners.
National finalists for the 2010 Telstra Business Women’s Awards
COMMONWEALTH BANK BUSINESS OWNER AWARD
- Yvette Adams, The Creative Collective, QLD
- Corinne Bot, Polyglot Group Pty Ltd, NSW
- Jan Ford, Jan Ford Real Estate, WA
- Heather Malone, Penny’s Fancy Dress, NT
- Melissa Mellen, Murray F. Young & Associates (MFR), SA
- Sharon Pearson, The Coaching Institute, VIC
- Kristi Seymour, 41 Degrees Real Estate, TAS
- Kate Sykes, CareerMums Pty Ltd, ACT
HUDSON PRIVATE AND CORPORATE SECTOR AWARD
- Karin Adcock, Pandora Jewelry, NSW
- Jane Bennett, Ashgrove Cheese, TAS
- Jill Coombe, Bridge Clinic, SA
- Denise Goldsworthy, Rio Tinto, WA
- Megan Houghton, City Smart, QLD
- Janet Matton, IBM Australia Ltd, VIC
- Carol Sawyer, Canberra Southern Cross Club Ltd, ACT
WHITE PAGES COMMUNITY AND GOVERNMENT AWARD
- Janet Buhagiar, St Vincent de Paul Society, NT
- Catherine Carter, Property Council of Australia, ACT
- Margaret Flynn, CentaCare, Wilcannia-Forbes, NSW
- Jo Harrison-Ward, Fire and Emergency Services Authority (FESA), WA
- Nicole Highet, beyondblue, VIC
- Debra Howe, Toowoomba Regional Council, QLD
- Tanya Monro, Institute for Photonics & Advanced Sensing, SA
- Amanda Quealy, The Hobart Clinic, TAS
NOKIA BUSINESS INNOVATION AWARD
- Brenda Ainsworth, ACT Health, ACT
- Jessica Blackwell, Equestricare, WA
- Marnie Douglas, Ergoworks Physiotherapy and Consulting, NSW
- Dr Kirsten Heimann, School of Marine and Tropical Biology, James Cook University, QLD
- Robyn Lewis, VisitVineyards.com, TAS
- Kris Lloyd, Woodside Cheese Wrights, SA
- Louise McCormick, Department of Construction and Infrastructure, NT
- Alexandra Wardle, Minki Moop Pty Ltd (Qubies), VIC
MARIE CLAIRE YOUNG BUSINESS WOMENS AWARD
- Lee Broomhall, Workpower Incorporated, WA
- Lauren Brown, Pulse Marketing Group, NSW
- Janet Buhagiar, St Vincent de Paul Society, NT
- Melanie Gordon, BHP Billiton Mitsubishi Alliance, QLD
- Peta Mantzarapis, Maloney Field Services, SA
- Kate Morris, Adore Beauty, VIC
- Teena O'Keefe, Dance Fit, TAS
- Carly-Jane Tozer, CJ’s Style, ACT
TELSTRA AUSTRALIAN BUSINESS WOMAN
- Karin Adcock, Pandora Jewelry, NSW
- Jane Bennett, Ashgrove Cheese, TAS
- Denise Goldsworthy, Rio Tinto, WA
- Megan Houghton, City Smart, QLD
- Heather Malone, Penny’s Fancy Dress, NT
- Janet Matton, IBM Australia Ltd, VIC
- Melissa Mellen, Murray F. Young & Associates (MFR), SA
- Kate Sykes, CareerMums Pty Ltd, ACT
For further information on the Telstra Business Women’s Awards: www.telstrabusinesswomensawards.com
Media contacts:
Telstra – Kathryn McFarlane: 0419 850 201
Lighthouse Communications Group – Natasha Ciesielski: 0428 480 710 / 02 9262 3868
www.telstra.com.au/abouttelstra/media-centre/
Download press release
Telstra Business Women's Awards Network